Home Project Copilot

Contractor estimate review

See exactly what you get before you pay a cent

A contractor estimate review for homeowners: the whole output is on this page — a complete sample report, line-by-line estimate teardowns, what is included at each price, who it is for, and straight answers to the questions people ask before buying.

Scan my estimate free Read the full sample report
  • Private & SSL encryptedUploads travel over HTTPS and land in private storage. Nothing is public.
  • Never shared with contractorsYour estimate is never sent to contractors, lead buyers, or advertisers.
  • Files deleted in 90 daysUploads are erased 90 days after your report — or sooner, any time you ask.
  • Free scan, no cardSee your red flags before paying anything. Payment is optional.

What the review actually contains

$12 for one estimate · $19.99 to compare up to three estimates on the same project. One payment, no subscription.

Every finding in plain English

Each flag says what the estimate actually says, why it matters in money terms, and what to ask — no jargon, no grading of the contractor's character.

Scope gaps and loose wording

Missing line items, open-ended allowances, undefined materials, and terms that let the final invoice land higher than the bid.

A cost range for your state

Your quoted price against typical regional costs for that trade and scope, with the assumptions shown.

The message to send your contractor

A copy-and-send list of specific questions, written so it reads as diligent rather than hostile.

A completion punch list

What to verify before the final payment, so the last 10% of the job does not get quietly skipped.

Side-by-side bid comparison

On the multi-bid review, a matrix of what each estimate includes, excludes, and leaves undefined — and what could explain the price gap.

The output, in the app

This is the real report interface running on an anonymized roofing project with three estimates. Click through the tabs — nothing is hidden behind a form.

Interactive demo — anonymized roofing project

Three estimates: $18,400, $22,750 and $28,100. Click through what the review returned.

  • Tear-off is not stated on the lowest bid

    High priority

    Tear-off materially changes both the cost and the manufacturer warranty. Without it in writing, the price is not comparable to the other two bids.

    Ask: “Does this price include complete tear-off and disposal of the existing roof, and how many layers are you expecting to remove?”

  • No decking replacement allowance on two of three bids

    Review

    An unpriced item discovered mid-job is negotiated at your weakest moment, with the roof already open.

    Ask: “What is your installed price per sheet of replacement decking, and will you photograph any sheets you replace?”

  • Flashing wording is open-ended

    Review

    Step and valley flashing are where most roof leaks begin. Reused, bent, or corroded flashing is a common source of callbacks.

    Ask: “What would it add to replace all step, valley, and chimney flashing with new material?”

Run this on my estimate — free See the whole report

Estimate teardowns

Composite examples built from estimate patterns we see repeatedly — anonymized and not any one customer's documents. Each one walks the same path your own report takes.

Roofing · $14,800Roofing estimate teardown: $14,800 for a 28-square tear-offThe price itself was defensible. The problem was that four of the biggest cost drivers on a roof — decking, ventilation, flashing, and the deposit schedule — were either missing or written so loosely that the final invoice could land thousands higher.Read the teardown Bathroom remodel · $27,500Bathroom remodel teardown: $27,500 with $9,000 of undefined allowancesA third of this quote was allowances — money set aside for products nobody had chosen yet. Allowances are normal. Allowances without a per-item number, a spec grade, and a written change-order threshold are how a $27,500 bathroom becomes a $36,000 bathroom.Read the teardown Deck build · $18,600 / $23,100 / $28,000Deck proposal teardown: three bids, $9,400 apart, for different decksThe homeowner assumed they had three prices for one deck. They actually had prices for three different decks: different decking material, different footing depth, and only one bid that included the permit and engineered plans an elevated deck required.Read the teardown

Who this is for

  • You have at least one written estimate in hand
  • The job is big enough that a missed line item costs real money
  • You are about to approve work or pay a deposit
  • You have two or three bids and they are hard to compare
  • You are handling an insurance restoration scope

Who this is not for

  • You have no written estimate yet — get one first
  • You want someone to tell you a contractor is dishonest
  • You need a licensed inspection, appraisal, or engineer's report
  • You want legal advice about a contract dispute
  • You are the contractor looking to price-check your own bid

About the examples on this page

We do not publish customer testimonials, savings figures, before-and-after photos, or project results, because we have not yet collected permissioned, redacted material from real customers. Publishing invented ones would be exactly the kind of thing this service exists to catch. Everything here is either the genuine product output or a labelled composite example. When homeowners give us permission to publish their redacted estimates and outcomes, they will appear on this page and be labelled as such.

Questions homeowners ask before buying

What is a contractor estimate review?
You upload the estimate a contractor gave you. We read it line by line and tell you what is missing, what is written too loosely to hold anyone to, how the price compares to typical costs in your state, and the exact questions to ask before you approve the work.
How much does it cost?
The red-flag scan is free and needs no card. The full review is $12 for one estimate, or $19.99 to compare up to three estimates for the same project side by side. There is no subscription.
How long does it take?
The free scan comes back in about 20 seconds. The full report is generated right after payment, and you also get an email with a private link to it.
Do you publish customer results or testimonials?
Not yet. We only publish material we can stand behind, and we have not yet collected permissioned, redacted estimates or quotes from customers. Everything shown on this page is either a complete sample report or a clearly labelled composite example built from common estimate patterns — not a real customer's documents.
Is my estimate shared with contractors?
No. Your uploads are stored privately, are never shared with contractors or sold, and are deleted 90 days after your report — or sooner, any time you ask at support@homeprojectcopilot.com.
What will the review not claim?
It is an independent, AI-assisted second opinion — not a licensed inspection, an appraisal, an engineering judgement, or legal advice. It will not tell you a contractor is dishonest, and it cannot see anything that is not in your documents and photos.
What if my estimate turns out to be fine?
That is a normal and useful outcome. You get written confirmation of what is covered, what the price compares to, and a short punch list to check at completion — which is exactly what you want before paying a deposit.
Can I use it after I have already signed?
You can, and homeowners do it to prepare for change orders or final payment disputes. It is most valuable before you approve the work or pay a deposit, while you still have leverage.

Start with the free scan

Upload your estimate, see what gets flagged in about 20 seconds, then decide whether the full review is worth $12.

Scan my estimate free